—Jill Hunter 教授《颠覆美好的认知：反思证据法的失败》 述评

戴晓东

（中国政法大学，北京 100088 ）

【摘 要】交叉询问制度有其固有缺陷，盲目引入并不能真正促进庭审中心主义发挥实效。所以，我们需要对交叉询问制度进行必要的反思，这也是 Jill Hunter 教授《颠覆美好的认知：反思证据法的失败》 一文的中心思想。通过对该文的介绍和评述，可以从中获取对我国交叉询问制度构建的有益启示。

【关键词】交叉询问；固有缺陷；反思；启示

【中图分类号】D915.13

【文献标识码】A

【文章编号】1674-1226（2017）01-0030-13

Examining the reasonableness of the cross-examination system: reviewing professor jill hunter’s “battling a good story: cross-examining the failure of the law of evidence”. Dai Xiaodong. China University of Political Science and Law, Beijing 100088.

【Abstract】The system of cross-examination has its inherent defects,blindly transplanting whichinto China legal system cannot really promote the substantial effects of the trial centralism. Therefore, we need to reconsider the cross-examination system, which has been discussed in Professor Jill Hunter’s "Battling a Good Story: Crossexamining the Failure of the Law of Evidence”. Byreviewing this article, we could obtain many useful insights on how to construct a cross-examination system in China.

【Key Words】 Cross-examination, Inherent defects, Rethinking, Enlightenment